
Amy Fluker presents to the Brookfield Historical Society in October 2025.
In writing about ghost stories of the Civil War era, Amy Fluker reminded herself that history itself is a kind of haunting.
“It’s the past that comes into the present and sometimes it’s troubling to us,” said the Youngstown State University associate professor of humanities and social sciences and a Civil War historian.
One of the parts of America’s past that most troubles us today is the Civil War. Even though the fighting ended 160 years ago, the legacy of slavery, the constitutional debate over the rights of states versus the power of the federal government and the unprecedented loss of American lives continues to fuel discussions, tweak emotions and generate more questions about ourselves as Americans.
“Everybody’s lives were touched by loss associated with this war in some way,” Fluker told the Brookfield Historical Society in October 2025. “It is absolutely no surprise that Americans are haunted by this war and its aftermath.”
It took 15 years to research and write “Haunted by Memory: Ghost Stories of the American Civil War,” which was published by the University of Tennessee Press. The first 10 years were handled by Dr. John R. Neff, Fluker’s dissertation adviser. After he died in 2020, Neff’s wife asked Fluker to pick up the pen. She said she spent a year just going through Neff’s materials before she set out on her own research venture, which included reading old newspapers, military service records and court-martial files.
Nineteenth-century Americans very much believed in the supernatural and ghost lore, she said. “This did not run counter to the very strong Protestant Christianity that also characterized this era. They were able to believe in ghosts and still very much believe in their evangelical Protestant Christianity.”
Many people did not find ghosts to be scary or carry a sinister intent. Instead, they believed that ghosts and hauntings served a purpose, such as to reveal an injustice, name a murderer or fulfill a pact. It also was common to believe that God had willed the ghost to come back to earth.
Faith also helped people deal with the loss of one or more people close to them, or the extent of the loss caused by the war, which historians still can’t put a firm number to. The Civil War “shattered the Victorian notion of the good death,” which involved someone passing at home, surrounded by friends and loved ones, after having professed his or her faith, Fluker said. The deceased would be buried in a plot that loved ones could care for, she said.
“None of this is possible in the context of the American Civil War,” Fluker said. Soldiers often died anonymously, were buried on the battlefield and their families were never informed what happened to them.
Civil War veterans, many of whom were traumatized by the loss of a friend, the slaughter of a unit and the general hellish conditions of battle, told ghost stories and the language of ghosts was common in explaining their experiences, such as amputees suffering phantom limb syndrome.
“Looking at Civil War ghost stories has a couple of different kinds of value,” Fluker said. “One is that if we take the beliefs of 19th century Americans in ghosts seriously, we understand them better, we understand the culture and society and world view of people in the Civil War era. I also think talking about Civil War ghosts can help us understand the ways in which so many legacies of this conflict are still controversial. The idea that somehow the Civil War is over just isn’t quite true in a lot of ways.”
All this talk of ghosts hasn’t scared Fluker off of the subject. She plans to write a book about the first documented ghost story in the United States, she said.
“Haunted by Memory: Ghost Stories of the American Civil War” is available from Barnes and Noble, Google and Amazon.

